What was Jiddu Krishnamurti's Relationship with Yoga || By Mark Whitwell

 

     BKS Iyengar, Yehudi Menuhin and J. Krishnamurti 

Truth is a Pathless Land


It was Krishnamurti who said to my teacher Desikachar, “Don’t become one more monkey.” Don’t become a guru; don’t exploit the gullibility of the public in this idea of being a ‘knower.’ 

We must profoundly see the non-necessity and the obstruction produced by these corrupt social orders that created civilization in Europe and in Asia. No one can be second to anything or anybody and no one can be superior to anything or anybody. My teacher U.G. Krishnamurti (no relation to J Krishnamurti) had a lovely statement “No one should be a slave to anybody.”



In his lifetime J. Krishnamurti displayed a paradoxical and hidden relationship to Yoga where he would say one thing and do another. In his private life he was a devoted practitioner and lifelong student of Desikachar and Krishnamacharya. In his public teachings however he was dismissive of Yoga as either spiritual seeking or merely as a means to attain bodily health. 
Together with his father, Desikachar simplified Krishnamurti’s home practice. He removed the headstand, showed him how to breathe in asana and pranayama, and taught him how to move with a new quality of effortlessness. Krishnamurti enthusiastically took to this new regime: 

“Truth is a pathless land,” Jiddu Krishnamurti famously declared in 1929, before stepping down as the world leader of Theosophy. “Man cannot approach it through any organization, through any creed, through any dogma, priest or ritual, not through any philosophical knowledge or psychological technique.” 

In other words, if you are trying to get to truth on a path, then that path is leading away from truth. Truth is the given condition of all Life: your hands holding your phone; your eyes reading these words; the vibration of all life happening is truth. This understanding was Krishnamurti’s profound and beautiful offering to the world. 

I loved Desikachar for walking that line. On the one hand, he was his father’s son and Krishnamacharya was a great patriarchal authority figure and scholar within his own Vaishnava religious tradition. In his own lifetime, Krishnamacharya was never quite able to give up that role of the ‘knower.’ Although he made magnificent efforts to do so and to be beautifully humble. He said, “Whoever says he is a guru is not a guru.” 

But it was Desikachar, with the help of J. Krishnamurti, who really finished the job of ending the male authority ‘knower’ position. He walked through his life honouring the authority of his father’s knowledge by bringing it into the world as a friend to everybody. My statement about Desikachar is that he attained ordinariness. Whenever the cultural tendency to be the boss appeared in him he would correct himself. 

The paradox of J Krishnamurti’s life however, is that even as he dissolved his position as the world leader of Theosophy and rejected the guru role he nonetheless remained a spiritual or philosophical authority. He was still the special person on the stage talking to the crowd who did not yet ‘know.’ The serious point to be made here is that if spiritual transmission, even love transmission, occurs within a hierarchy then it simply does not work. It is a love that makes you sick. 

At the same time, we must attain ordinariness with each other. In that ordinariness as human beings who love and care for one another in local community, we share the tantras of Yoga. The tantras of each person's direct intimacy with and participation in Life as it actually is. The Given Reality that some cultures call God, Nurturing Source, Truth. Not the typical Yoga of trying to get to truth that Krishnamurti was rightly dismissive of. But the Yogas of participation in truth. 

J. Krishnamurti and Yoga

Jiddu Krishnamurti’s interest in Yoga was sparked through his friendship with BKS Iyengar. The two met via the famous violinist Yehudi Menuhin in Saanen, Switzerland in the early 1950s. And for many years Iyengar taught Krishnamurti a vigorous gymnastic practice. 

A decade later, Jiddu travelled to Madras to seek out the renowned Yoga teacher and guru to Iyengar: T. Krishnamacharya (1888-1989). Krishnamacharya was well known by many theosophists and friends of Krishnamurti as a great teacher. Because his health was not improving under Iyengar’s guidance, he asked Krishnamacharya if he would help him deepen his understanding of the practice. Krishnamacharya asked his son TKV Desikachar to teach.  

In his book Health, Healing, and Beyond Desikachar described their first lesson in December 1965: 

“Before beginning our first lesson, I expressed a desire to see Krishnaji’s yoga practice. He was ready in no time. In spite of his 69 years, the postures he demonstrated were of the most advanced nature—all the variations of headstand, shoulder stand, hand balance, and many difficult back arches. And although his frame was small and the postures varied and stupefying, his chest was as tight as a barrel. I also noticed that his breath was restricted and panting, his hands trembled, his neck was like granite, and his eyes sometimes rolled with tears.”

“Krishnaji was so keen to learn that I saw him every day, some days more than once. I was amazed at his remarkable ability to adjust to this new instruction, so contrary was it to the instruction which he had previously received and practised. In a few weeks, there was no trace of previous training.”

With respect and tact shown towards BKS Iyengar, who was Desikachar’s uncle and a frequent participant in Krishnamurti’s gatherings in Saanen, Desikachar took over as Krishnamurti’s personal teacher. Desikachar reflects how Krishnamurti had a tremendous enthusiasm for the subject and always showed up for lessons on time. Krishnamurti became so committed to the teachings that he offered to finance Desikachar’s studies, “Sir, if necessary, I will sell my shirt and send you money, but please study; you must.” Later, he left a message for Krishnamacharya requesting that he teach his son everything he knew. Desikachar later said that Krishnamurti’s interest made him become a better student of his own teacher. 

For the remainder of his life, Krishnamurti practiced Yoga for an hour per day (sometimes two) finding it useful in keeping his body healthy and for clarity of mind. His favorite definition of Yoga was “Shanti” or Peace.  

The mountains at Ojai where Jiddue Krishnamurti set up the Pepper Tree buildings. Photograph by Mark Whitwell 

Say One Thing, Do Another

Despite J. Krishnamurti’s passionate interest and respect for Yoga, he never made it part of his public teachings nor did he give it to his followers en masse. In many of his talks, he dismisses Yoga as altogether separate from the kind of non-dual spiritual realization that he was trying to communicate:

“You can practice yoga, the exercises of different kinds. The speaker has done some of it for years. But you can do this kind of yoga exercise for the rest of your life, you won’t awaken spiritual insight”-Brockwood Park 1979 

It was Krishnamacharya and Desikachar’s firm view however that if you are in a relationship with a realizer like Krishnamurti then Yoga was absolutely necessary. Yoga was the practical response that you could do if you receive or perceive Grace in the company of a person like Jiddu. It was the means by which any ordinary person could participate in the clarity of their embodiment and maintain clarity in their everyday circumstance.

Without Yoga, Krishnamacharya would say, the beautiful non-dual ideals of a realizer like Krishnamurti would remain other to the recipient and the mind will remain fixated on two. 

Many of the people around J. Krishnamurti remained frustrated in their lives because they had no way to respond to his presence or teaching. The mood around him was often one of frustrated seekers who were trying to understand and live what he was saying but with a sense of failure and disappointment. They would then judge themselves perpetually for not being able to understand him. 

In his wonderful book The First and Last Freedom one seeker asks: “When I listen to you, all seems clear and new. At home, the old, dull restlessness asserts itself. What is wrong with me?” This is a common predicament when inspiration is taught outside of a Yoga context. 

Jiddu Krishnamurti had a presence, a real beauty and he had his own realization that he was at one with the universe. But he didn’t necessarily have the culture and knowledge that goes with that realization which can make it useful to the ordinary person. 

It is sad that Krishnamurti was unable to make the connection between the Yoga that Desikachar and Krishnamacharya taught him and its vital relevance for his followers.

The realization that Krishnamurti had under the pepper tree in Ojai is the natural state of all human beings. We are all at one with the cosmos. We ARE the cosmos and each person is a beautiful, utterly unique flower blooming in their own garden. Yoga is the practical means of participating in this fact. When we move and breathe according to the principles that Desikachar taught we feel the obvious truth of Life. By having our own Yoga, we can fully enjoy and make use of the fruits that saints and sages like J. Krishnamurti bring forth. 

TKV Desikachar and Mark Whitwell underneath the Pepper Tree at Ojai where J. Krishnamurti had his famous realization.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Mark Whitwell has been teaching yoga around the world for many decades, after first meeting his teachers Tirumali Krishnamacharya and his son TKV Desikachar in Chennai in 1973. Mark Whitwell is one of the few yoga teachers who has refused to commercialise the practice, never turning away anyone who cannot afford a training. The editor of and contributor to Desikachar’s classic book “The Heart of Yoga,” Mark Whitwell is the founder of the Heart of Yoga Foundation, which has sponsored yoga education for thousands of people who would otherwise not be able to access it. A hippy at heart, Mark Whitwell successfully uses a Robin Hood “pay what you can” model for his online teachings, and is interested in making sure each individual is able to get their own personal practice of yoga as intimacy with life, in the way that is right for them, making the teacher redundant. Mark Whitwell has been an outspoken voice against the commercialisation of yoga in the west, and the loss of the richness of the Indian tradition, yet gentle and humorously encouraging western practitioners to look into the full depth and spectrum of yoga, before medicalising it and trying to improve on a practice that has not yet been grasped. And yet Mark Whitwell is also a critic of right-wing Indian movements that would seek to claim yoga as a purely hindu nationalist practice and the intolerant mythistories produced by such movements. After encircling the globe for decades, teaching in scores of countries, Mark Whitwell lives in remote rural Fiji with his partner, where Mark Whitwell can be found playing the sitar, eating papaya, and chatting with the global heart of yoga sangha online. Anyone is welcome to come and learn the basic principles of yoga with Mark Whitwell.